The location where Kelly Sue Bunting was found

Crime Scene Location Melville, New York

This is the location where serial killer Robert Shulman dumped the body of Kelly Sue Bunting.

It is situated at 1875 Walt Whitman Road in Melville, New York.

At the time of the murder, the property belonged to a company called FRP Sheet Metal Contracting. These days, the building appears to be vacant.

Bunting was a sex worker who operated on Jamaica Avenue in Hollis, Queens. At the time of her death, she was using the name Melani Vilavencencio.

Shulman picked Bunting up on December 8th, 1995, and brought her back to his apartment in Hicksville.

The two knew each other, as she had visited his residence in the past. According to another sex worker whom Schulman had previously hired, he was angry at "Melani" because he believed she had stolen cocaine from him.

When Bunting and Shulman arrived at his house in Hicksville, they reportedly smoked crack together. However, at some point during the night, he became so filled with rage that he "lost control" and beat her to death with a dumbbell.

Following the murder, he removed her hands and wrapped her body in a sleeping bag. He then placed her remains in a dumpster behind this property on Walt Whitman Road.

1875 Walt Whitman Road
This Google Street View image of 1875 Walt Whitman Road was captured in November 2020. Note that some sources refer to it as "Old Walt Whitman Road." At the time of the murder, the property was being used by FRP Sheet Metal Contracting.

Schulman removed Bunting's hands because he knew that investigators would attempt to identify her by running her fingerprints through the system. However, he overlooked a tattoo on her chest that read "Melani."

On the morning of December 11th, 1995, a worker at FRP Sheet Metal Contracting discovered Bunting's remains in the dumpster while he was searching for a misplaced lottery ticket.

The police were able to trace the victim's identity by publishing a photograph of her tattoo in the local newspaper. After receiving an anonymous tip from the public, they learned that their Jane Doe was a sex worker who was last seen getting into a blue Cadillac with a white male in Hollis, Queens.

Schulman was so well known by sex workers in the Hollis area that they instantly recognized his vehicle and were able to lead detectives to his address.

Bunting was Schulman's fifth victim. She also proved to be his last, as her identification ultimately led to his capture.

Location

The address and GPS coordinates for the property are as follows:

Address

1875 Walt Whitman Road, Melville, New York, NY 11747, USA

GPS Coordinates

40.767845, -73.426470
40°46'04.24"N 73°25'35.29"W

Get Directions

Open this location in your preferred maps app:

Area Information

Melville is situated in Suffolk County on Long Island.

📍 The property is about 250 yards (230 meters) west of the intersection between Broadhollow Road and Walt Whitman Road.

Visualize on map
Map Viewer

There is more than one location associated with this entry. To view all of these places on the same map, you can use the following feature:

View Map

This location belongs to the following categories:

Crime ScenesSerial Killers

Closest Locations

Other locations that are relatively close to this address:

The house where Amber Lynn Costello was last seen

Roughly 6 miles away.

Crime Location in West Babylon, New York

Rex Heuermann's storage unit

Roughly 7 miles away.

Place of Interest in Amityville, New York

Rex Heuermann's house

Roughly 7 miles away.

Suspect House in Massapequa Park, New York

Robert Shulman's house

Roughly 8 miles away.

Serial Killer House in Hicksville, New York

The Amityville Horror House

Roughly 9 miles away.

Crime Location in Amityville, New York