The cemetery where Jessica Keen was murdered

This is the cemetery where Jessica Keen was murdered.

It is called Foster Chapel Cemetery, and it is located on NE Plain City-Georgesville Road in Plain City, Ohio.

Keen was a 15-year-old cheerleader who started struggling at school after she began dating an older high school dropout named Shawn Thompson.

When she quit cheerleading and her grades suffered, her parents checked her into Huckleberry House, a shelter for troubled and at-risk teenagers in Columbus.

Keen's parents hoped that the counseling sessions at the crisis center would help their daughter get her life back on track.

On the evening of March 16, 1991, the teenager disappeared from a COTA bus stop near Summit Street in the Weinland Park neighborhood of Columbus, just one day before she was due to return home. The following day, her body was found in this cemetery in Madison County, roughly 18 miles away.

She had been raped and beaten to death with a piece of a gravestone.

It is believed Keen escaped from her abductor at the cemetery and hid behind the headstones. However, he caught her as she attempted to flee through a fence at the back.

Foster Chapel Cemetery.
She attempted to hide behind some of the tombstones.

Although Keen's boyfriend quickly became the prime suspect in her murder, DNA evidence eventually ruled him out.

As a result, the case went cold for 17 years.

In April 2008, it was announced that a convicted rapist named Marvin Lee Smith Jr. had been arrested for Keen's murder.

Mugshots of Marvin Lee Smith Jr.
Smith Jr. agreed to plead guilty to the crime. His next parole hearing is scheduled to take place in 2038. By then, he will be 81 years old.

During the mid-late 1990s, the state of Ohio began collecting DNA samples from inmates who had been convicted of violent crimes. The trace evidence from Keen's crime scene was a match with Smith's DNA.

In February 2009, Smith agreed to plead guilty to murder to avoid the death penalty. Two months later, he was sentenced to 30 years to life in prison.

Address

The address and GPS coordinates for the cemetery are as follows:

Address

NE Plain City-Georgesville Rd, Plain City, OH 43064, USA

GPS Coordinates

39.995457, -83.263307
39°59'43.65"N 83°15'47.91"W

Get Directions

Open this location in your preferred maps app:

Area Information

The cemetery is about fives miles west of Columbus, Ohio.

Closest Locations

Other locations that are relatively close to this address:

Last Seen Location · Columbus, Ohio

The bar where Brian Shaffer went missing

Roughly 17 miles away.

Crime Location · Columbus, Ohio

The club where Dimebag Darrell was killed

Roughly 18 miles away.

Crime Location · Mount Vernon, Ohio

Matthew Hoffman's house

Roughly 61 miles away.

Filming Location · Mansfield, Ohio

Shawshank State Prison

Roughly 85 miles away.

Serial Killer House · Lorain, Ohio

Samuel Little's childhood home

Roughly 144 miles away.