Mary Pewitt's house

This is the house where Mary Morgan Pewitt was murdered.

It is situated at 611 South 10th Street in the small town of Comanche, Oklahoma.

On the night of June 3rd, 1988, Pewitt finished her shift at Harold's Club on West Main Avenue. The 25-year-old had only started working at the bar two weeks prior.

After closing up and bringing the cash receipts over to the owner's house, she returned to her home, where her friend, Randy Benson, was waiting for her.

Benson said that they watched television together until roughly 12.45 a.m., at which point he left.

The following morning, Pewitt's mother, Elizabeth, arrived at the house to drop off her two granddaughters, whom she had babysat the night before.

When Elizabeth knocked on the front door, her daughter didn't answer. While they were standing on the front porch, waiting for Pewitt to open the door, one of the girls ran to the front of the house and peered in through the bedroom window.

There, sprawled out on the bed, was her mother, unresponsive and covered in blood.

Pewitt had been stabbed 30 times in the neck and chest. She also had defensive wounds on her hands, which suggested that she had seen her killer coming towards her with a knife.

Although she was only wearing socks and a t-shirt, there were no signs that she had been sexually assaulted.

Instead, it appears as though her assailant slashed at her from the front until she was no longer able to defend herself.

The evidence indicated that the attack began in the living room and led to the hallway before eventually ending in the bedroom.

The nature of the murder suggested that Pewitt knew her killer. This is because, statistically speaking, a person who stabs their victim dozens of times is most likely experiencing intense emotions such as jealousy and rage.

The problem, from the investigators' perspective, was that Pewitt had a complicated love life. By her mid-twenties, she had already been divorced twice. She was also estranged from her third and current husband, Stan Pewitt.

Although Stan was reportedly physically abusive toward her, he was in jail on the night in question.

Pewitt's past marriages, coupled with the fact that she had several male friends, made it difficult for detectives to identify a strong suspect.

As a result, the case eventually went cold.

KWTV News 9 investigated the murder in 2022. After speaking to Pewitt's daughter, reporters learned that Randy Benson had changed his story.

Benson, who passed away in 2020, initially told investigators that he left the house at 12.45 a.m. However, he later claimed that he had left at 11.50 p.m. because he needed to get home "before midnight" so that he could play video games with his son.

When News 9 contacted Benson's son, he declined to say whether or not his father was present that night. Despite "not wanting to get into it," he did insinuate that his father had lied:

"I don't know if you remember the old Nintendo or not, but I mean, almost all [Nintendo games] were one-player games."

Since the murder, this house has retained its notoriety. In Comanche, few have forgotten the killing that took place behind that picture window at 611 South 10th Street. Students from nearby schools often walk by the property on a daily basis, sharing urban legends about how it is haunted.

To this day, Pewitt's murder remains the town's only cold case.